Thinking about retiring in Canada or the United States? In this video, we break down the real financial differences between the two countries—comparing income taxes, OAS clawbacks, Social Security and CPP benefits, healthcare costs, estate taxes, currency exchange, and overall cost of living. You’ll see why many higher-income retirees often pay significantly less tax in the U.S., how Canada’s OAS can be reduced or eliminated, why healthcare can offset U.S. tax savings, and how estate rules like the U.S. step-up in basis can dramatically impact heirs. If you’ve lived or worked in both countries, this is the side-by-side financial comparison you need before deciding where to retire.
Watch the video here:
Need More Help?
Are you interested in working with a financial planner specializing in cross-border financial planning? Schedule a complimentary meeting below, and let’s simplify your cross-border financial plan.
Summary
Retiring in Canada vs. the U.S.
Bryan discussed the financial implications of retiring in Canada or the United States for Canadian residents who have worked in the U.S., highlighting significant tax differences, healthcare, government benefits, and estate taxes. He emphasized the importance of considering factors like currency risk and OAS clawbacks when making this decision. Bryan, a certified financial planner and chartered financial analyst, specializes in helping cross-border families simplify their retirement planning between the two countries.
US vs Canada Retirement Taxes
Bryan discussed the significant differences in income taxes between retiring in the US and Canada, using a comparison of tax burdens for retirees in North Carolina (US) and Ontario (Canada) at different income levels. For a couple receiving $60,000 in Social Security, CPP, and OAS benefits, US taxes would be zero, while Canadian taxes would exceed $6,000, with the tax differential narrowing at higher income levels. Bryan noted that once income exceeds approximately $120,000 Canadian dollars, taxes in Canada can spike into a 50% marginal tax bracket, resulting in a nearly $20,000 difference in taxes compared to the US for higher earners.
Government Benefits: U.S. vs Canada
Bryan explained the differences in government benefits between retiring in the U.S. and Canada. He noted that Social Security and CPP benefits are the same regardless of where one retires, but OAS benefits can be reduced or eliminated in Canada if income exceeds certain thresholds. Bryan highlighted that retiring in Canada could result in a substantial reduction or elimination of OAS benefits for higher-income earners, while lower-income earners might qualify for the GIS benefit, which is not available in the U.S.
U.S. vs. Canada Healthcare Costs
Bryan discussed the significant difference in healthcare costs between retiring in the U.S. and Canada. In Canada, healthcare costs are minimal, with some clients opting for supplemental plans costing around $1,000 annually. In the U.S., Medicare provides good coverage but can be costly, with individuals paying $5,000 to $6,000 per year, and families potentially exceeding $10,000 to $12,000 annually. Bryan noted that while U.S. healthcare offers better access to doctors and quicker procedures, some prefer Canada’s lower costs despite longer wait times.
U.S. vs. Canada Estate Taxes
Bryan explained the differences between U.S. and Canadian estate taxes, noting that the U.S. has an estate tax that only applies to individuals with over $15 million or couples with over $30 million, while Canada does not have an estate tax but can impose significant tax burdens on heirs due to the lack of a step-up in cost basis and the inclusion of RSPs and IRAs in taxable income upon death. Bryan highlighted that U.S. estate taxes are generally lower and more favorable, allowing heirs to benefit from a step-up in cost basis and tax-free transfers from registered accounts like IRAs.
U.S. vs. Canada Retirement Costs
Bryan discussed the financial implications of retiring in the U.S. versus Canada, highlighting how currency exchange rates can significantly impact the value of assets when moving between the two countries. He noted that Canadian-based assets might lose value when converted to U.S. dollars due to the current exchange rate, while U.S.-based assets could gain substantially in value when converted to Canadian dollars. Bryan also mentioned that the cost of living in Canada is generally higher than in the U.S., with more expensive homes and goods, as well as higher sales taxes. He concluded that while financial considerations are important, other factors, such as family, personal comfort, and the political environment, also play a role in deciding where to retire.
Cross-Border Retirement Financial Insights
Bryan discussed the financial implications of retiring in the United States versus Canada, noting that while U.S. income taxes are generally lower, healthcare costs and government benefits like OAS can be more favorable in Canada. He noted that estate taxes tend to be friendlier in the U.S., and many clients find it financially beneficial to retire south of the border. Bryan introduced a cross-border retirement calculator to help estimate benefits and encouraged viewers to schedule a free consultation with a cross-border consultant for personalized advice.